Calorie Count
subscribe Signup for our Newsletter expand Expand Browser
Calorie Count Blog

5 Great Reasons to Kick Your Diet Soda Habit


By ismile67 on Jul 15, 2012 06:00 PM in Healthy Eating
By Audrey Quinn, You Beauty

You Beauty

Why you should say sayonara to this bad-for-you beverage.

Chances are, you already know that diet soda is too good to be true. With that sweet taste and zero calories, something's gotta give. And chances are, it’s your waistline and your health.

In fact, study after study shows that diet soda is likely failing you in its pounds-free promise and putting your health at risk at the same time.

Researchers have linked drinking diet soda with:  

Weight Gain

Diet soda drinking correlates with both increased waist circumference and a heightened body mass index. What's up? One possible explanation is that diet soda disrupts our ability to feel full. Scientists have found that, at least in rats, having something artificially sweetened before a meal leads to greater food consumption at chow time. In general, sweet tasting foods and drinks appear to increase our appetite.

RESEARCH:   Fake Sugars Cause Weight Gain  

Higher Sugar Consumption 

“The intense sweetness of these products primes the brain to want more of the regular sweeteners, ” says Lora Sporny, adjunct associate profession of nutrition and education at Columbia University Teachers College.

Artificially sweetened drinks activate our sweetness response, but don't completely satisfy it, leaving you craving more of the real thing. This can drive us to eat more sugary foods than we would normally. 

Kidney Problems

Julie Lin, M.D., a kidney specialist at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston, studied the soda habits and kidney health of more than 3,000 women for 11 years.

“What we observed,” Dr. Lin says, “was an association between drinking two or more servings of diet soda per day and faster kidney function decline.” In fact, the kidneys of diet soda drinkers declined at three times the rate typical of aging.

You don't want to mess with your kidneys, notes Lin. “They're really one of the most important organs for keeping our whole body in balance in terms of processing the waste that the body generates just from our daily food intake,” she says. Even just moderate kidney decline goes hand-in-hand with an increased risk for cardiovascular disease.

MORE:  Should There Be a Diet Soda Tax?  

Increased Diabetes Risk

“If you're a consumer of diet soda, you have a higher risk of developing metabolic syndrome than a non-consumer,” says Lyn Steffen, Ph.D., R.D, a professor in the division of epidemiology and community health at the University of Minnesota.

Here’s why that’s bad news: Metabolic syndrome involves a deadly combination of abdominal obesity, elevated blood pressure, low HDL cholesterol, high triglycerides (fatty acid derivatives linked to heart disease and stroke) and elevated glucose (high blood sugar)—all of which increases the risk of diabetes, coronary heart disease and stroke. 

Steffen studied thousands of people over nine years. At the end of the study, she looked at the study subjects’ diets and whether they had developed metabolic syndrome. She found that the greatest predictors of someone getting the syndrome were those who consumed meat-heavy diets, fried foods and diet soda. Other researchers have linked diet soda drinkers with a 67 percent greater risk of developing full-fledged type 2 diabetes. 

MORE:  Which Sweeteners Are Bad For You? 

Stroke

A January 2012 study in the Journal of General Internal Medicine found that people who guzzle diet soda daily have a 43 percent higher risk of vascular events—such as stroke and heart attack—than people who don't drink diet soft drinks. However, light diet soda drinkers—those who sipped diet soft drinks somewhere between once a month and six a week—were not more likely to suffer vascular events.

So what can you do if you're truly hooked on diet soda? While drinking water is the best way to quench your thirst, the truth is, that doesn’t always make for the most appetizing replacement. “For most people,” says Sporny, “the weight of water isn’t great enough to make it appealing to them. When fluid becomes a bit heavier, it's more palatable.”

That's why both Sporny and Lin recommend seltzer water as your swap of choice. Carbonation is a naturally calorie-free way of putting some extra oomph in your glass. If you still want some sweetness to your drink, mix a bit of fruit juice with your seltzer and sip away.

MORE:  Diet Soda Boosts Risk of Heart Attack & Stroke 

Your thoughts...

Do you have a diet soda habit?  Or have you kicked a diet soda habit?



Comments


I finally kicked my soda habit this year!   I was drinking several a day...but now water is my friend!   The other day I had a diet soda...just because I wanted to, and I took one sip and it felt like gasoline going down my throat.  It was disgusting.  I couldn't believe that I had been putting that into my body for so long.  

 

Now...it's time to kick the coffee!



The seltzer works.  I was a at least 4 a day Diet Coke drinker since about 1985.  In January I bought a Soda Stream and started drinking the carbonated water with a slice of lime and lemon as my replacement.  I have not had a diet soda since then.  I have had about 4 of the small cans of Sierra Mist since then as my only soda. I considered those a treat when the craving for soda really hit.  I now can drink straight water and the Bubble water is my treat.  The first week or so is torture with the caffeine withdrawal, but it is soooo worth it.    



I kicked the soda habit several years ago.  Now I have only about six sodas in a year, but I do enjoy each one of them.  When I get tired of plain ice cold water, I drop an herbal tea bag in my glass or water bottle with a squirt of agave syrup for a change of pace.  Try different flavors, they are great.



Hello all! I am in the process of trying to kick my soda habit wanted to know what everyone's thoughts are on diet green tea? Would like to limit my liquid intake to the diet green tea and water. I know the diet tea probably has the same sweeteners as diet coke...


Does anyone else find this to be questionable?  I drink diet soda and don't feel that it has any negative affect on my weight loss.  I am sure that anything with artificial ingredients in it may cause problems with your kidneys and liver but I simply don't by the other affects they claim.  As far as green tea it would be basically the same as a soda. 



I gave up soda years ago and replaced it with water.  However, I add flavor to it  by using the Hawiian Punch singles that are only 5 calories.  What I need to know is the potential negative effect of the artificial sweeteners in this product.

If any one has any information I would appreciate it.

Thanks in advance.



but it tastes so good...



This is day 3 without diet soda for me; I still need caffine though because I seem to be getting headaches; they are a lot less mild then when i was drinking diet soda all the time.



@Melindag16 Believe me, cutting out the soda is HARD (I did soda and caffeine at the same time) but just put up with the headaches for a week or two longer. In the long run, its not really a huge period of time. Your body is probably going through caffeine withdrawl- you'll be amazed at how you don't feel tired in the middle of the day and need your "fix" after a while! And how much of a boost you'll get when you do have the ODD cup of coffee or soft drink. To think we've been drinking that every day!



@lissisluu I am aiming for one at a time right now because I already have migranes and don't want to make them any worse. I hope it won't be to hard, I've gone through some life changes within the past year and hoping this one will not be any different. I went from being 235 to 164 right now and just trying to stay and be healthy; this seemed like another way to accomplish that :)



flavored spring water like Poland spring or flavored seltzer water with a lot of ice and a squrit of flavor enhancer like MIO is delicious and refreshing O cal O sodium



Couldn't it be that the people who consume diet soda are also more likely to be involved in other unhealthy lifestyle choices that lead to these negative effects (stroke, diabetes, reduced kidney function)...?



The same handful of studies are cited in every article that links weight gain with diet soda, and the test groups were really small and the results, as far as I know, have not been replicated. It's true that the rats had a certain psychologically reaction to the sweeter sweetness of diet soda, but there's no proof that the same thing happens to humans. And the thing about the large waist lines of people who drink tons of diet soda only has to do with the fact that lots of folks who have terrible eating habits also drink diet soda. People who buy a double big-gulp of diet pepsi to go along with their seven hotdogs. In the last six months since I've been trying to lose wieght I still drink 2-3 cans of diet soda a day, and I've lost twenty pounds.  



Original Post by: swirligirl

but it tastes so good...


I suspect that your Hawaiian Punch contains aspartame since there are few soft diet drinks that don't. Aspartame is a neurotoxin which I avoid at all costs. Please Google the "evils of aspartame" and you will find additional info on this deadly chemical sweetener. There are a few diet drinks such as 4-C powdered drinks, Arizona Iced Tea, and the new Pepsi product "Pepsi One" which are made with sucralose (Splenda is a brand name of sucralose.) However, sucralose has also been found to cause numerous ailments including rashes and dizziness.

The only sweetener I use on rare occasions is Stevia which is relatively benign (unless future research proves otherwise). I add a packet of Stevia to a glass of flavored seltzer or homemade iced green tea and I enjoy these beverages occasionally when I want a little break from all the water I drink.



Original Post by: beluomo

Original Post by: swirligirl

but it tastes so good...


I suspect that your Hawaiian Punch contains aspartame since there are few soft diet drinks that don't. Aspartame is a neurotoxin which I avoid at all costs. Please Google the "evils of aspartame" and you will find additional info on this deadly chemical sweetener. There are a few diet drinks such as 4-C powdered drinks, Arizona Iced Tea, and the new Pepsi product "Pepsi One" which are made with sucralose (Splenda is a brand name of sucralose.) However, sucralose has also been found to cause numerous ailments including rashes and dizziness.

The only sweetener I use on rare occasions is Stevia which is relatively benign (unless future research proves otherwise). I add a packet of Stevia to a glass of flavored seltzer or homemade iced green tea and I enjoy these beverages occasionally when I want a little break from all the water I drink.


Sorry, my response was meant for marciaaustin



Original Post by: marciaaustin

I gave up soda years ago and replaced it with water.  However, I add flavor to it  by using the Hawiian Punch singles that are only 5 calories.  What I need to know is the potential negative effect of the artificial sweeteners in this product.

If any one has any information I would appreciate it.

Thanks in advance.


Please read my response to you which I mistakenly posted to "swirligirl".



@beluomo Thanks so much for the information.  Hawiian Punch indeed has Aspartame.  I will do research on this to find out the side effects.  Stevia sounds like a better alternative.  My daughter has also recommended it along with Agave syrup.  I am open to all things that will help me lose the weight and stay healthy.Smile



Original Post by: srice74

Hello all! I am in the process of trying to kick my soda habit wanted to know what everyone's thoughts are on diet green tea? Would like to limit my liquid intake to the diet green tea and water. I know the diet tea probably has the same sweeteners as diet coke...

If your going to drink the diet green tea for a long time expect bowel issues.  Regular green tea is fine but there's something in the diet that makes you 'go' and pretty soon you'll 'go' without being anywhere near a toilet.



Okay, here is my analysis of this article. If you had an ant in an ant eater habitat drinking diet soda and the morality rate of the ants was higher than the normal ant life expectancy would you say that diet soda causes ants to die prematurely? What? that made no sense! Who drinks diet soda? Overweight people right... Who has a higher risk of all them symptoms..... over weight people.... So just because they happen to be drinking diet soda(to try to lose weight) doesn't mean that they are having these problems because of the diet soda.

 

I think it's silly to base research on , well i find in common all these fat people are drinking diet soda that must mean something..... maybe it just means fat people drink diet soda cause they think it's healthy and no other similiarty.



And furthermore, you only test people when something happens so if 99% of diet soda drinkers dont have problems they will never be in the research so the 1% that complain make it look like a big issue. Do what your body tells you to do.


Post Your Comment

Join Calorie Count - it's easy and free!
CREATE FREE ACCOUNT
Advertisement
Recent Blog Post
Turkey-rific Taco Bean Dip
A savory and spectacular bean dip you can make in a crock pot? YUP. Call your friends. It's party time!  


Advertisement