Bob or Jillian..??

Both are freakin' AMAZING..

But who would you rather have for your trainer and why?

I don't know - at least the parts that get aired seem way too focused on cardio, and the contestants' form for weight lifting almost always sucks, and neither corrects it.

Jillian only because she would get more on my a** if I wasn't giving it my all..I think Bob might be a little more forgiving, but I might take advantage of that. :P I wouldn't mind either though. :)

Bob!

He seems more sympathetic. He would listen to me whine for a while and then gently convince me to get going. Jillian has more of a shut up and do it attitude. I would resent that.

Original Post by azirra:

Bob!

He seems more sympathetic. He would listen to me whine for a while and then gently convince me to get going. Jillian has more of a shut up and do it attitude. I would resent that.

 after last night's episode, i wouldn't be too sure haahaha! bob lost his ****!!!! it was kinda scary. jillian was cracking up. cuz he totally sounded like her. LOL.

I'd say Jillian just cuz i know she'd bust my butt and make me give everything I've got!

P.S. soooooooo pissed that joelle didn't go home! She's not even trying! Ugh it makes me so angry!  Come on you watched the show, you should know you have it give your all!! Her lazy half assed attempt at everything was ridiculous!

Original Post by girlfighting27:

I'd say Jillian just cuz i know she'd bust my butt and make me give everything I've got!

P.S. soooooooo pissed that joelle didn't go home! She's not even trying! Ugh it makes me so angry!  Come on you watched the show, you should know you have it give your all!! Her lazy half assed attempt at everything was ridiculous!

 I can't believe she didn't take the 25K????  She can't possibly think she'll win!  I would have laughed if she got kicked off... off the show and no money.

Oh yeah - I'd pick either trainer!

Bob for sure although Jillian is great also.  I like to be motivated not screamed at.  I like this group alot better than the last one.  I really like that gal who went down the hill to help Daniel? get up the hill.  Really supportive which is especially needed i think for a young guy trying to lose such a large amount of weight. 

Tara went down the hill to help. I liked her for that, too. I hope she takes it! Oh, probably Bob for me. 

Jillian. I'd never expect her to go easy on me (and she wouldn't) so I'd have to give her everything I've got. No matter whether Bob lost it on last night's episode or not, I'd expect him to be merciful at least sometimes.

I'll have to wait for one of the many rebroadcasts to catch last night's episode, since my DVR didn't deign to record it while I was out.

Original Post by misskady:

Tara went down the hill to help. I liked her for that, too. I hope she takes it! Oh, probably Bob for me. 

 I love Tara! she's seems like a genuinely good hearted person.  And when she gave her phone call away, *tear* I loved her even more! Oh and thank god she won immunity!

up until last night's episode, i would have said jillian.  i think if i was to have a trainer, i'd want one who would push me, because i'm lacking in the ambition to work out department.

yeah, if i had to choose, jillian.

Not to go completely off subject, but let me just say I am SO glad that the competitors this time are supportive instead of back stabbing like last season. These people seem more genuine and have the right idea for the main reason of the show. YES! :)

Original Post by silentdeadlyrose:

Not to go completely off subject, but let me just say I am SO glad that the competitors this time are supportive instead of back stabbing like last season. These people seem more genuine and have the right idea for the main reason of the show. YES! :)

 unfortunately, i fear i have to say "give it time..."

but thus far, they do seem alot more supportive, which is awesome!

Jillian without question! She is tough and honest and I love that. Last night was the first time I saw Bob show any balls and the first time I actually liked him I hope I see more of it! If I do I would say either could train me if not I stick with Jillian

Jillian,

She doesn't take any crap! I wish Like hell I had a chance to train with her.

Definitely Jillian : )  And I totally love Tara - I hope she wins this season!!!  And yes, this season's contestants are already TONS better than last season *thank goodness* : )

Jillian.  everytime i start to think she's a cold hearted brat, she then says something really sweet.   strangely enough, i think bob is waay more condescending and rude than jillian.  

also, i really like tara too and all the contestants are really likable (except for joel, so far).

I love this show and it keeps me motivated, especially Jillian.  Love Bob to pieces, and would train with him had I the chance.  All in all though, when I don't want to work out, it's Jillian that pops into my head and tells me to get off my duff and get working!  I have some of her DVD's and love them!

I so wanted Joelle to go.  I do not feel she is taking full advantage of where she is and the opportunities at the Ranch!  I really thought she was going to take the money.

Bob. I just like him better. Jillian is too over the top for my liking, I wouldn't do well trying to train with her. I like firm but not so rude and aggressive just for the sake of being rude and aggressive. It pushes me in the other direction -- I know that's just my personality.

[And I was really ticked off that Joelle didn't volunteer herself last night to go.]

Joelle could've had 25k!  She should have taken the money and run!