Foods
Moderators: ksylvan, sun123



cookies!!!! which one is right!?!??!


Quote  |  Reply

ahhh so on calorie count the cookies chocolate chip regular from recipie etc are just 78 calories for one cookie, but then all the other ones with brands on them (from subway, nestle, whatever) are like 210 and 300 calories.... WHICH IS RIGHT?!?!?! i just had a regular sized homemade cookie, like 2 inches in diameter or whatever, so what does that count as....? going CRAZY!! thanks in advance...

5 Replies (last)

I would think that a homemade cookie would have less calories than packaged cookies...preservatives and stuff like that are in packaged cookies.  you are probably ok with the 78 or so estimate.  Maybe 100 just to be safe.  I love those 100-calorie pack snacks they have out now...then I dont have to worry about counting...the chocolate covered pretzels are yummy!!

Impossible to tell, but I am guessing more then 78 calories. I made oatmeal cookies. I used PB2, regular oatmeal, whole wheat flour, egg substitute, and light oil and it came out to 100 calories per cookie. With regular butter, eggs, and more sugar instead of PB2, it would have been much more. I would go with ~200.

UD

What size was your cookie? Stick one on the scale and find out how much it weighs... a very small cookie has far fewer calories than a big one.

I made a pumpkin pie and I was shocked that calorie counter said that it had 300 calories a slice - then I put one of my slices onto the scale and discovered that it was only 2 oz instead of the 150g CC was estimating. So the calorie count was much much lower...

Depends on the size of the cookie.

Baking cookie isn't very hard. You can make whole grain and nearly fat free cookies at home! just replace whatever oil or butter with applesauce!

If you made the cookies, you know what's in 'em. Why not log it all into the recipe analyzer and find out how much it really is for each serving?

5 Replies (last)
Join Calorie Count - it's easy and free!
CREATE FREE ACCOUNT
Advertisement
Your Personal Nutritionist
Featured question:

How can I fight depression during dieting?

Regardless of whether or not someone is dieting, depression is treated by medications and psychotherapy. The mental health therapist... Read more