what do you do when the guy you like offers you a cookie?

I take the cookie.  lol, keep in mind i'm in highschool dealing with highschool guys. 

it was a veeeeeery good cookie.  of the chocolate chip variety.  :)  What would you do?  Any advice? 

Either

Throw it away or

Give it away or

Feed it to a dog or

Freeze it as a reminder of him

I'd say thank you very much and that I'm going to save it for later.

Yep. Dont take it and eat it. He may think you LOVE cookies and shower you with them. Just smile, thank him earnestly, and say something like "Thats so sweet of you! Mm, it looks good, but I'm a little full. I might save it for later. Thanks!"
If you dont want to take it (or if you didnt) maybe give HIM something later. Maybe not a cookie, but something of a similar vein.

i guess.  he's just so sweet cause he never gives anyone a whole cookie but he gave one to me!  lol.  I'm just a sap. 

i think freezing it was a good idea.  :)  thanks all.

i would have totally taken the cookie! 

work it off later...hopefully with hot mr. highschool man. 

LOL.  omg i love this site. 

I totally took it.  it was DARN good.  hehe. 

Yep, I would take the cookie too!!!  If you guys start being an item, time enough then to ask him to not shower you will cookies! :o)

How sad is this! The guy I liked my sophomore year gave me 3 Hershey's Kisses one day on my way to class.  I saved the wrappers and little streamer things and taped them in my yearbook later.  That was 24 years ago and I looked at my yearbooks with my daughter the other day-those wrappers are still there.  :o)

We did begin dating about 3 weeks after that and then on and off for about 6 years.  When we were in college, I once told him about the wrappers and he laughed his rear end off. 

"work it off later...hopefully with hot mr. highschool man."

HAHAHA omg. I love you now. XD

Thats so cute.

Cookies...

That's adorable. :)

Take it and split it with him! He'd probably feel honored that you'd return his kindness (and HA you get half the calories). Or just eat it. One cookie won't make a dent.

Now eating fifty of the same kind of cookie at home to remember his chivalrous act will make a dent.

Break it into little bites and slowly feed it to him, letting him know he's already sweet enough for you. 

or

Throw it on the floor and stomp on it and scream "Mosh Party"

I'd take the cookie!  hahahaa!!!  That was sweet of him :)

Like i said, i thought it was super ubder sweet because he NEVER gives away food.  He loves his cookies and he just said i could have one!  *melts*  He broke up with his girlfriend (who was a total &*^^(%) a while ago and he's been talking to me. 

eeee.  awesome responses.  you guys crack me up.   

that happened to me a while ago with a guy friend that i liked as a friend not a guy guy. (<<um lol?)

we shared a cookie and it was yum. who cares! i don't buy cookies on my own so it's all good.

awww!  i would've taken the cookie too ;)

i'd eat the cookie - Cookie Monster style.... smashing it into my face...oh, oops...wrong dream...

no, no... i'd take the cookie and say thank you very much and that i'm gonna save it for later. unless it is hot from the oven - in which case, i would have to eat it right away, sharing of course with boy. i might even leave a smudge of chocolate on my lip so that he could...um... lick his finger and touch my face... and then our eyes would meet and we'd embrace each other and kiss passionately....

i should write a romance novel!

Eat it of course- unless you are allergic.

dude, nobody came up with SHARE the cookie? with the guy who gifted it?

oops. my bad.