Foods
Moderators: ksylvan, sun123



Why is meat rated an D & F?


Quote  |  Reply

I have noticed that meat is rated either D or F, even tuna and chicken, anybody know why?

Edited Apr 05 2009 16:41 by nycgirl
Reason: Moved from Weight Loss to Foods forum
10 Replies (last)

Person who grades food is a vegetarian? Tongue out

No, I have no idea.

#2  
Quote  |  Reply

What meats are you looking at?  The only one I had that was a D was Bacon.  Ground beef, roast beef, sirloin,  pork roast, grilled chicken, ham were all either B's or C's.

i haven't seen any meats as an F, most are B's and C's, tuna is A

Not sure where you are looking, but the grades vary by meat..they aren't all Ds or Fs. So, look again. I've posted the first page of different types of meat..hope this helps :)

  1. B   Chicken, Breast, Meat Only - Cooked, Roasted
  2. B   Chicken, Breast, Meat Only - Cooked, Stewed
  3.     (Tyson FoodsFresh Boneless, Skinless Chicken Breasts - Chicken Products/Uncooked Chicken Products/Fresh Chicken
  4. B   Chicken, Breast, Meat Only - Cooked, Fried
  5. B-  (Foster FarmsBoneless Skinless Breast Fillets - California Grown Fresh Chicken Breast
  6. B-  Chicken, Meat Only, Roasted
  7.     (PerdueR.P.C. Boneless Skinless Chicken Breast SNGL - Refrigerated Portion Control
  8. B-  Chicken, Breast - Meat And Skin, Cooked, Roasted
  9.     (Foster FarmsBoneless Skinless Breast Fillets - Individually Frozen Chicken
  10. B   Chicken, Roasting, Light Meat, Meat Only - Cooked, Roasted
  11. B   (Organic ValleyBoneless, Skinless Chicken Breast, frozen - Meat/Poultry
  12. B-  Chicken - Breast, Fillets, Skinless & Boneless, Raw
    1. B+  Turkey Breast Meat
    2.     (PerdueDeli Sliced Turkey Breast
    3. B   Turkey, All Classes, Meat Only - Cooked, Roasted
    4.     (Boar's HeadOvengold Roast Breast of Turkey - Skinless - Poultry
    5. B   (Oscar MayerDeli style Turkey Breast Smoked - Cold Cuts
    6.     (Healthy ChoiceOven Roasted Turkey Breast - Deli Thin
    7. B-  (Oscar MayerOscar Mayer, Turkey Breast (Smoked, Fat Free)
    8. B   (Oscar MayerOven Roasted White Turkey - Cold Cuts
    9. B+  Turkey, White, Rotisserie, Deli Cut
    10. B   (Kraft Foods, Inc.Louis Rich, Turkey Breast And White Turkey (Oven Roasted)
    11.     (Boar's HeadMaple Glazed Honey Coat Turkey Breast - Poultry
    12. B   (Sara Lee Bakery GroupSara Lee Premium Honey Roasted Turkey Breast - Turkey/Poultry Whole Muscle
    13.     (Healthy ChoiceSmoked Turkey Breast - Deli Thin
    14. B   (Kraft Foods, Inc.Louis Rich, Turkey Breast And White Turkey (Smoked Sliced)
    15. B   Turkey, All Classes, Light Meat - Cooked, Roasted
    16.     (Foster FarmsFresh Ground Turkey - Lean - Fresh Turkey Ground Turkey
    17. B-  Turkey, All Classes, Breast - Meat And Skin, Cooked, Roasted
    18. A-  Turkey, Fryer-roasters, Breast, Meat Only - Cooked, Roasted
    19. B   (Oscar MayerSmoked White Turkey - Cold Cuts
      1. B+  Pork, Fresh, Loin, Tenderloin - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Roasted
      2. B+  Pork, Fresh, Loin, Sirloin (Chops), Boneless - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Broiled
      3. D   Pork, Cured, Bacon - Cooked, Broiled, Pan-fried Or Roasted
      4. B   Pork, Fresh, Loin, Top Loin (Chops), Boneless - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Pan-fried
      5. B   Pork, Fresh, Loin, Top Loin (Chops), Boneless - Separable Lean And Fat, Cooked, Broiled
      6. B   Pork, Fresh, Loin, Whole - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Roasted
      7. B-  Pork, Fresh, Loin, Center Rib (Chops), Boneless - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Pan-fried
      8. B+  Pork, Fresh, Loin, Top Loin (Chops), Boneless - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Broiled
      9. B   Pork, Fresh, Ground, Cooked
      10. B-  Pork, Fresh, Shoulder, Whole - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Roasted
      11. B   Pork, Fresh, Loin, Country-style Ribs - Separable Lean And Fat, Cooked, Braised
      12. B   Pork, Fresh, Loin, Top Loin (Roasts), Boneless - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Roasted
      13. B-  Pork, Fresh, Loin, Country-style Ribs - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Roasted
      14. B-  Pork, Fresh, Loin, Center Rib (Roasts), Boneless - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Roasted
      15. B   Pork, Fresh, Loin, Center Loin (Chops), Bone-in - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Pan-fried
      16. B   Pork, Fresh, Loin, Top Loin (Chops), Boneless - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Braised
      17. C-  Sausage, Italian, Pork, Cooked
      18. B   Pork, Fresh, Loin, Top Loin (Chops), Boneless - Separable Lean And Fat, Cooked, Braised
      19. B   Pork, Fresh, Loin, Sirloin (Chops), Bone-in - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Broiled
      20. B+  Pork, Fresh, Loin, Tenderloin - Separable Lean Only, Cooked, Broiled
      21. B-  Pork, Fresh, Loin, Blade (Chops), Bone-in - Separable Lean And Fat, Cooked, Braised
      22. B-  Pork, Fresh, Loin, Whole - Separable Lean And Fat, Cooked, Roasted
      23. B+  Pork, Cured, Ham, Boneless - Cooked, Unheated
      1. B   Salmon, Atlantic, Farmed - Cooked, Dry Heat
      2.     (Market DayTilapia Fillets
      3. B+  Tuna, Light, Canned In Water - Without Salt, Drained Solids
      4. A-  Salmon, Atlantic, Wild - Cooked, Dry Heat
      5. B+  Salmon, Pink - Cooked, Dry Heat
      6. C   (WegmansTilapia - Fresh Seafood
      7. B+  Tuna, Light, Canned In Water, Drained Solids
      8. A-  Shrimp, Mixed Species - Cooked, Moist Heat
      9. B+  Cod, Atlantic - Cooked, Dry Heat
      10. B-  Tuna, White, Canned In Water, Drained Solids
      11. A-  Halibut, Atlantic And Pacific - Cooked, Dry Heat
      12. A-  Flatfish (Flounder And Sole Species) - Cooked, Dry Heat
      13. B-  Fish Fillet, Battered Or Breaded, And Fried
      14. A-  (Bumble BeeBUMBLE BEE Solid White Albacore in Water
      15. C-  (StarKist FoodsStarKist Chunk Light Canned Tuna
      16.     (StarKist FoodsStarKist Premium Solid White Albacore Tuna
      17. B+  Haddock - Cooked, Dry Heat
      18. A-  Tuna, Yellowfin, Fresh - Cooked, Dry Heat
      19. B   (Bumble BeeBUMBLE BEE Chunk Light Tuna in Water
      20. A-  Roughy, Orange - Cooked, Dry Heat
      21. B   Salmon, Coho, Wild - Cooked, Moist Heat
      22. B   Catfish, Channel, Farmed - Cooked, Dry Heat
      23. B   Salmon, Chinook, Smoked
      24. B+  Snapper, Mixed Species - Cooked, Dry Heat
      25. C+  Tuna Salad
      1. B-  Lamb, Loin - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      2. B   Lamb, Cubed For Stew Or Kabob (Leg And Shoulder) - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Cooked, Broiled
      3. B   Lamb, Leg, Shank Half - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      4. B   Lamb, Leg, Whole (Shank And Sirloin) - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      5. B-  Lamb, Shoulder, Blade - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      6. C+  Lamb, Ground - Cooked, Broiled
      7.     Lamb - Chops, Minted
      8. B-  Lamb, Leg, Sirloin Half - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      9. C+  Lamb, Loin - Separable Lean And Fat, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Broiled
      10. B-  Lamb, Loin - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Broiled
      11. C+  Lamb, Rib - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      12. B-  Lamb, Shoulder, Arm - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      13.     (WegmansFYFGA Rack of Lamb, roasted
      14. B-  Lamb, Composite Of Trimmed Retail Cuts - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked
      15. B-  Lamb, Cubed For Stew Or Kabob (Leg And Shoulder) - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Cooked, Braised
      16. B-  Lamb, Rib - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Broiled
      17. B-  Lamb, Foreshank - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Braised
      18. B-  Lamb, Leg, Shank Half - Separable Lean And Fat, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      19. C-  Lamb, Composite Of Trimmed Retail Cuts, Separable Fat, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked
      20. C+  Lamb, Leg, Whole (Shank And Sirloin) - Separable Lean And Fat, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      21. C   Lamb, Loin - Separable Lean And Fat, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      22. C+  Lamb, Loin - Separable Lean And Fat, Trimmed To 1/8" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Broiled
      23. B-  Lamb, Shoulder, Arm - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Broiled
      24. B-  Lamb, Shoulder, Whole (Arm And Blade) - Separable Lean Only, Trimmed To 1/4" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted
      25. B-  Lamb, Leg, Shank Half - Separable Lean And Fat, Trimmed To 1/8" Fat, Choice, Cooked, Roasted

Thanks Chrissy!  I just looked myself.  The only beef I found that was a D was a corned beef brisket.  There was some Starkist Solid white Albacore in water that got a D--I honestly think that one is a misteak.

OP, you're going to have to be specific to where you got your information.

I don't know about D's and F's, but I think a lot of meat gets graded down because of cholesterol or saturated fat content.  Personally though, I wouldn't put too much stock in CC's grading system - there are plenty of foods on there that get poor grades and are perfectly healthy and beneficial as part of a balanced diet

I'm from Canada and I find that a lot of our brand name foods are not on here so i input my info myself. I find the same thing, meats are a D or an F, my sole I bought always comes up as a D and my chicken also. I still eat them though.

its true that if you're putting in your own meats in the grades will get a D or F. This is because the items listed on CC include a bunch more nutrients than just the 4 you given on packages (Vitamin A, Vitamin C, Calcium, and Iron). If you click any item and click the "see more extended nutritional details" located under the nutrtional facts, you'll see there's more nutrients listed.

Yeah, I have noticed that fresh salmon consistently gets a D. I thought it was supposed to be healthy with all of the omega-3 fats you get from it. I don't know the criteria CC is using to grade foods...

if you're putting a single ingredient into your log and analyzing, you might get a D or an F because it's not balanced.

10 Replies (last)
Join Calorie Count - it's easy and free!
CREATE FREE ACCOUNT
Advertisement
Advertisement
Your Personal Nutritionist
Featured question:

Where is the Recipe Analyzer located?

The Recipe Analyzer is under the Foods tab. Use these steps to analyze a recipe: Find a recipe to analyze; note the number of servings... Read more