| Forum | Topic | Date | Replies |
| Weight Loss | the eat every 2 hour theory | Feb 23 2012 01:13 (UTC) |
4 |
|
Well, I think I'll just throw another log on the fire and keep this baby burning with my critique of registered dieticians. Let me say, I'm sure many are very qualified and dispense good advice. But as with doctors, just because someone has some initials after their name doesn't mean they know everything. The field of nutrition is changing all the time and information taught in school can quickly become outdated. Also note that much of what RDs are taught relates to working in an institutional setting (think school setting for example). Here is a great article written by someone studying to be an RD that critiques his own field (scroll down to item #5, "The American Dietetic Association isn't a Health Organization"). http://smallbites.andybellatti.com/5-ways-in- which-the-nutrition-field-hinders-its-own-pro gress/ I'm not trying to piss anyone off...what I am encouraging is to be open-minded ~ there is so much incorrect and/or outdated information that people cling to as truths. Educate yourself. And just because a doctor or an RD said something doesn't make it true. |
|||
| Fitness | Just Started Cardio & Weight Loss, A Few Questions | Feb 23 2012 00:56 (UTC) |
21 |
|
Change one small thing at a time. Don't overthink it. Start with diet first. Fix your eating habits ~ you cannot lose weight without the diet being in place. Focus on real food as much as possible. Figure out the food thing first, then slowly start adding the exercise. Small changes generally have a better way of sticking. I think you made the mistake that most people do, just starting off super enthusiastic and trying to do it all at once. We all want to see quick changes, but I think you will be more successful if you focus on one small thing at a time. As I mentioned above, I think John Berardi at Precision Nutrition is a super smart dude when it comes to weight loss. They have helped thousands of people lose weight and they coach people to make very small changes at any one time. Google John Berardi "top 10 lessons for 2012" or check out my blog (link is in my profile). I think it is a very useful article. In the end, everybody is different. Find what works for you. If it's not working, change something and try again. Keep at it until you find what works for you. It's not rocket science...it's just hard to do! Good Luck! |
|||
| Foods | Whey protein vs soy protein for weight loss | Feb 22 2012 22:16 (UTC) |
2 |
|
Agree with smallmac264...I avoid soy as much as possible. Most soy in this country is genetically modified (which presents a host of questions as to its safety, aside from the fact that all GMO crops are sprayed heavily with herbicides). I also agree to be careful of whey protein sources ~ they are not tested and popular brands have in the past been found to contain cadmium, lead, arsenic and mercury. I only use whey protein that comes from grass-fed cows. I understand having to eat on the go, but what about grabbing fruit and/or nuts, hard-boiled eggs or other "real food." Maybe thinking about it the night before and having something ready to grab as you head out the door. Real food always trumps supplements. |
|||
| Fitness | Just Started Cardio & Weight Loss, A Few Questions | Feb 22 2012 21:51 (UTC) |
24 |
|
You have obviously never heard of intermittent fasting. Do you have anything to back up your statement that "it is a fact that the majority of people who do not eat breakfast are overweight?" I don't care if you eat breakfast ~ if that works for you, that is great. I just have a problem with people who state things like "you must eat breakfast," "breakfast is the most important meal," or "it is a fact that the majority of people who do not eat breakfast are overweight." And for the record, I think the whole blood sugar thing is another load of garbage. If eating many small meals works for you, great, go for it. But it doesn't work for everyone and there is no reason anyone should feel they have to eat that way. I recognize everyone is trying to help on this forum but I just think there are too many people who state "rules" about eating that are not based on anything scientific.
|
|||
| Fitness | Elliptical to lose weight? | Feb 22 2012 17:14 (UTC) |
3 |
|
Diet first and foremost. Then strength training, then interval training. |
|||
| Weight Loss | the eat every 2 hour theory | Feb 22 2012 16:52 (UTC) |
18 |
|
AjithGunawrdana...if something works for you, that's great, but quite frankly it proves nothing (other than you believe that it works for you). Dispensing advice to others as "fact" when all you really know is that it works for you is irresponsible. Smashley did a good job of providing facts. If you all chose not to listen, then that's your choice. I eat 2-3 meals a day within an 8 hour window, a form of Intermittent Fasting (and I don't eat at all for 16 hours). I like feeling full when I eat. Eating 4-6 times a day does not work for me. There are many ways to eat, and people have to do what works for them. But there is no science to support the idea that you are storing fat if you don't eat multiple small meals throughout the day. |
|||
| Recipes | Healthy Alternative To Ice Cream | Feb 22 2012 01:35 (UTC) |
5 |
|
Same idea with the ice cream, with the addition of gluten free "cookie dough balls" made from a few healthy ingredients. |
|||
| Fitness | Need help with abdominal muscles | Feb 21 2012 20:01 (UTC) |
3 |
|
I like Paloff presses ~ there are a bunch of variations, cable chop and cable lift, stir-the-pot (on a stability ball) and all manner of planks (side versions too). The core is meant to be a stabilizer, so focus on exercises that use it as such. Go to youtube for video clips. Here is the basic Paloff Press to get you started: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzE553my1o8 And stir-the-pot: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EuMtm2MzRA |
|||
| Weight Loss | Breakfast Question | Feb 21 2012 19:54 (UTC) |
31 |
|
No one should be afraid of egg yolks. Cholesterol in food does not impact your cholesterol reading as your (amazing) body will adjust the amount of cholesterol it produces based on how much you get in your food. We have all been taught cholesterol is a bad thing, but you actually need it and your body produces it. I love to do scrambled eggs with a touch of parmesan cheese and spinach...a great way to get veggies into your meal. Personally I would stay away from all cereals and breads as they are highly processed and not in my book a "health food" (whole wheat or otherwise). Just my opinion. |
|||
| Recipes | Carbohydrate intolerant recipes or advice? | Feb 20 2012 12:25 (UTC) |
8 |
|
Lots of great paleo recipes online. A paleo diet eliminates all grains. |
|||
| Fitness | Eating after a work out? | Feb 17 2012 19:11 (UTC) |
1 |
|
I recognize the question wasn't about eating breakfast, but I want to be clear that I never said breakfast was "detrimental." In fact, I think I was supportive of different things working for different people. I think many of the "food rules" we have been bombarded with aren't really based on much of anything. It is very, very difficult to design good studies, and rarely do they definitely prove anything. I just think it is important to be open to different ideas ~ people shouldn't' feel they have to do something if it doesn't seem to work for them. There certainly is a lot of interest in the concept of intermittent fasting and a lot of people like it. These are not people whose health is suffering ~ in fact I would argue that many people embracing IF are very fit and healthy. |
|||
| Foods | egg White | Feb 17 2012 14:16 (UTC) |
4 |
|
Eat the whole egg. The yolk is good for you. |
|||
| Fitness | Eating after a work out? | Feb 17 2012 14:11 (UTC) |
5 |
|
I would try to take in carbs shortly after a workout ~ this is when your body can put them to use. My favorite post-lift meal is steel-cut oats with some protein powder (cinnamon, a touch of maple syrup, walnuts and diced apple too). Sometimes it takes me an hour after a tough workout to feel hungry though. I disagree with trh. Breakfast, in my opinion, is optional (I do intermittent fasting). I also think that you should listen to your body about hunger. Certainly you can get into eating disorder kinds of things where people decide they are never hungry and never eat, but I do not believe in eating because you think you're supposed to. Different things work for different people and for some (me included) eating a bunch of small meals throughout the day whether you are hungry or not does not work.
|
|||
| Fitness | Loss of muscle | Feb 17 2012 02:15 (UTC) |
4 |
|
I like Marianne Kane's workouts on myomytv. She focuses on good exercises that with a few kettlebells you can do at home. Different formats provide some variety. I would add back some strength training to avoid being "skinny fat" ~ thin but with no muscle. |
|||
| Weight Loss | best way to drop 15lbs by march 17th!!! | Feb 17 2012 01:59 (UTC) |
7 |
|
Stefj, I certainly hope you are joking.
|
|||
| Weight Loss | best way to drop 15lbs by march 17th!!! | Feb 17 2012 00:17 (UTC) |
10 |
|
You are not going to drop 15 pounds in one month without feeling hungry and doing damage to your body. Why do this to yourself? As Smashley says, get a bigger dress and start on a healthy weight loss program that doesn't involve garbage like hydroxycut. |
|||
| Fitness | Triathalon and weight training | Feb 17 2012 00:14 (UTC) |
1 |
|
A good discussion. I do think you can increase "raw strength" while increasing endurance. I see strength training improving strength and swimming, biking and running be more applicable to promoting endurance. I don't view weights as a productive means of the endurance piece. I believe you and I are both triathletes, so I am pleased we both agree that strength training is important ~ I would say a majority of triathletes don't. Seems the OP is planning to keep weight training, and that's the best outcome.
|
|||
| Fitness | Triathalon and weight training | Feb 16 2012 20:44 (UTC) |
3 |
|
I just don't think it is necessary to keep telling me my gym is ripping me off, which suggests that a) the guys there don't know what they are doing and b) I don't' know what I'm doing. Maybe you should google Cressey Performance. I am hardly getting ripped off. Or you could google Eric Cressey and Tony Gentilcore and see how little they know about S&C. I think people sometimes forget their manners in cyberspace when they aren't dealing with people face-to-face. I actually think generally you give good advice and have a good sense of humor. I'm done. |
|||
| Fitness | Squats with the Bar | Feb 16 2012 20:39 (UTC) |
8 |
|
Thanks, Solid. I will try not to take michaelduff's tone too personally ~ whether it's nasty, cranky or direct. I agree, he does know his stuff, and I too agree with him most of the time. In the end, it appears the OP was helped by michael and others, so all is well. |
|||
| Fitness | Triathalon and weight training | Feb 16 2012 20:21 (UTC) |
5 |
|
Okay, I'm not going to try to ruffle too many feathers here, but I am a strength coach myself, and I respectfully disagree with "training for endurance" with weights. It really doesn't do anything for you. The point of strength training is to...gain strength...which means building muscle. And you don't build muscle without progressive overload, meaning you progressively add weight as you get stronger. Smashley, I think you're just rude. What an endurance athlete does to train for their sport (e.g. running) is obviously different than what a basketball player does for his (e.g. playing basketball). But if you're going to strength train, then the point is to get stronger and there are not a lot of different ways to do it. Quite frankly, most trainers in a commercial gym setting really don't know much about proper strength training anyway, I don't hold much in what they say. Dede Griesbauer, a pro triathlete (you can goggle her, she's the real deal) trains at my gym and she does the same stuff as the pro baseball players do. Re: Mike Boyle, yes, controversial, but still a super smart dude, very nice and easy to talk to, willing to share his knowledge with everyone. He was recently appointed the S&C coach for the Boston Red Sox. The guy does know what he's doing even if he does piss people off sometimes. |
|||

