Foods
Moderators: ksylvan, sun123



Someone told me that


Quote  |  Reply

Cottage cheese make you fat. Or at least makes you gain weight. which i should have enough knowledge about this stuff to know that it doesnt, its the calories that would if you over ate on it.              But i just wanted a little reasurance lol.

Just Double checkin =]

13 Replies (last)

As long as you are eating with an overall calorie deficeit, I don't think you can logically gain weight (unless you're coming out of starvation mode.)  It's the overall calories, not the individual foods that count.
So, I'm calling BS on their cottage cheese comment.
I mean, I ate it everyday when I first started losing weight and I still lost, like, 20 lbs.
So, don't worry, enjoy your cottage cheese.

#2  
Quote  |  Reply

thanks  =]

There is no one food that, if eaten in moderation, will make you fat just by it's own nature.

So in the future, if anyone tells you such and such food will make you fat, it's BS.  Overeating makes you fat.  Pure and simple.

Your misinformed friend might have been drawing this conclusion because cottage cheese is a little high in sodium.  The sodium can make you retain a little water the next day if you eat too much, but it's not fat.  If you drink enough water, it shouldn't be an issue.

I was always told that cottage cheese was very good for weight loss.  High in protein, low in fat...although it is a bit high in sodium, but the 1% or 2% is lower in cals and you can do so many different things with it.  I personally love cottage cheese, and I am sure it is not hindering my weight loss.

When I was young, diet lunch plates typically had cottage cheese but regular without fat calorie reductions would be about 240 calories a cup LINK which didnt make it particularly dietlike.  My fat free has only 140 cal per cup though and its definitely good for those of us who dont get much dairy.
I agree with all of the above. I love cottage cheese, and eat the 1% fat organic one from Nancy's. So versatile, high in protein, yeah, your friend has got to be wrong :P

When I was seriously restricting during my ED, I ate cottage cheese for breakfast every morning. Certainly didn't make me fat.

Like every one else says, everythign in moderation. You would have to eat 25 cups of Skim Cottage Cheese (!) or 12.5 cups of Full-Fat Cottage Cheese in addition to your maitenance level in order to gain one pound. So chances are, you would exlode before you had the chance to gain any weight :P

they were probably making an ignorant comparison of cottage cheese thighs to the food. i love cottage cheese and it actually helps fill me up more then anything else.

There is no food that will "make you fat".  There are no bad foods--only bad diets.  Either your diet is balanced in nutrition and moderate in quantity (ie, calories), or it's not ... on a sliding scale, of course.  The closer you are to the balanced and moderate side, the healthier you'll be, including your body weight.  The more out of balance and not moderate you are (whether it's over eating or under eating) the less healthy and over/under weight you'll be.

I eat 1 % milk cottage cheese, I have lost a lot of weight eating this in the morning along with an apple or a pear....so I am not sure about what you heard. But it is only about 3 oz that I consume at a time.
is you eat lot of cottage cheese and full fat maybe yes, try fat free or 1% the only bad thing is the sodium, wich have lot of it, and if you eat tons of cans food you may bloated the next morning, and that cause weight gain...

Cottage cheese is a good way to get your serving of dairy and protein so if you're within your calorie allowance for the day it shouldn't make you gain anything. It is a little high in sodium so you'd want to make sure you don't go over your sodium allowance for the day.

13 Replies (last)
Join Calorie Count - it's easy and free!
CREATE FREE ACCOUNT
Advertisement
Advertisement
Calorie Count Challenge
Calorie Count Challenge
Ask your Friends:
Can you guess which one has fewer calories?
Start