I workout 4-5 days a week, 3 of which are just cardio days (no weight training) where I do about an hour of cardio, usually on the elliptical. After 60 minutes on the elliptical at mostly what is considered high intensity (75-85% of max. heart rate) including a 10 min. warm up and 10 min. cool down, the machine says I have burned about 700 calories. Does this seem to be a bit too much to anyone? Can I trust that this is fairly accurate?
No, I am pretty sure that the estimates on the machine are on the high side. I usually cut the number in half from what the readout is. There is another thread on this site that has a pretty good explanation. See post 12 in this thread:
http://caloriecount.about.com/elliptical-trai ner-calories-burned-ft3218
The way I arrived at the idea that in reality I only burned half of what the machine thinks, is by comparison with the cycling data found at http://www.caloriesperhour.com/ (they have an activity calculator that takes into account your weight, exercise time, and intensity level). I know from my past experience what biking at 12-15 mph feels like, and if I am working about as hard on the elliptical, I should be burning calories at about the same rate. For me this comes out to approx 400 cal/hr, but the elliptical says I burned that much in 30 min.
It all depends on what you weigh. I do the same workout everyday, and I know I burn about 800 calories an hour on the thing...not by what the machine says, but by what CC says. I have also done the math as far as my weight loss and the elliptical's part in it is concerned and I am satisfied that 800/hour is pretty close.
If you weigh around 165 I bet 700/hour is not too far off.

Figure out what type of eater you are and you might just find the answer to permanent weight loss.
Take the Diet Profile Test and learn to avoid the pitfalls and self-sabotage that often come with your personal profile.
