Wholesome Oatmeal Cookies

They're chewy or crispy, thick or thin, drop cookies or bars. It's the ever popular and healthy oatmeal cookie. Traditional oatmeal cookies are rich with butter, sugar and calories, but they don't have to be. We can cut the sugar and fat, and make our oatmeal cookies nearly as healthy as a bowl of hot cereal.
Great nutrition is our goal. Oats, oat bran, and oatmeal contain a specific type of fiber known as beta-glucan. Since 1963, studies have proven the beneficial effects of this special fiber on cholesterol levels. Oats are rich in antioxidants and provide important nutrients too. When looked at from a nutritional standpoint, oatmeal cookies make sense.
It's not hard to substitute more healthy ingredients if you understand what gives a cookie its texture. Fat, such as butter, cause the oats, flour and sugar to crisp up, just like frying potatoes. Eggs and flour bind the ingredients and make a cookie that doesn't crumble. If we leave out the fat, we will get soft, chewy cookies that are just as appealing. If we halve the fat instead of eliminating it, we can achieve the best of both with a little crispness outside and a softer interior. We can use egg whites or egg substitute and also whole wheat flour to cut calories and increase the food value of our cookies without sacrificing quality.
Here are some general tips:
- Some of the texture of your finished cookies will come from the kind of oatmeal you use. Old fashioned rolled oats are the chewiest and have the most texture. Quick or instant oats are cut finer and produce a less textured cookie. You can use either according to your own taste.
- What you add to the cookie dough provides variety. Dried fruits, nuts and seeds allow you to use your own special touch to make your cookies different from any others. A homely oatmeal drop cookie becomes a festive holiday treat with just the addition of a candied cherry and a little green colored sugar.
- Use your imagination, but follow the recipe to insure good results.
The right bakeware is important for success. Bake drop cookies on a good quality cookie sheet that is heavy enough not to buckle in the heat of the oven. The same goes for bar cookies - adjust your baking time to allow less time for dark colored pans and more for glass pans. Spray with non stick baking spray, lightly butter or oil the pan, or line your pan with parchment paper to cut down on clean up. Watch baking cookies carefully. The point at which they reach perfection is just a few moments away from the point at which they scorch or even burn. Turn the cookie sheet half way through the baking time to make sure they all brown evenly. Cool the cookies on a rack until completely cooled, especially if you are going to freeze them. If you freeze them, wrap in waxed paper and place loosely into a flat plastic freezer container to protect them from crumbling.
Great oatmeal cookie recipes abound. Here are just a few from Calorie Count members who have entered them using the Recipe Analyzer and that we found using the Recipe Browser.
Comments
I always use an egg replacer for my oatmeal cookies. My replacer of choice is ripe banana. It gives a fantastic flavor and is a much healthier choice
Nearly all the oatmeal cookie recipes I've tried end up too 'puffy' or cake like for my taste. I like them fairly flat and chewy. I know it's important to not over-cook them and it sounds like a lower fat content will work well for that too. Does anyone have a recipe that you KNOW gives that sort of result and is fairly healthy?
The funny part is they wrote this whole article about oatmeal cookies and did not include a recipe for a healthy oatmeal cookie. Even the one recipe they did include, Cranberry Orange Oatmeal cookie is not healthy and scored a C-....Calorie Count I am going to need you to do better.
adamae- I thought the same thing. I've found other oatmeal cookie recipes that are around 40-50 calories per cookie and don't use butter, oil, eggs or sugar.
I second what adamae121681 wrote. We might as well eat the original great tasting oatmeal cookies. Lots o' sugar and butter. lol
Try this on :
Healthy Oatmeal Cookies (with Honey)
Ingredients:
Dry ingredients
- 1 cup whole wheat flour (a pinch more depending on the moisture of the mix)
- 1 1/2 cups of Large Flake Rolled Oats (smaller flake is ok too)
- 1/2 tsp baking soda
- 1/2 tsp baking powder
- 1/2 tsp salt
- 1 Tbsp Cinnamon (I actually use about 3 Tbsp--got to love cinnamon)
- 1/2 tsp Nutmeg (optional)
Wet ingredients
- 1/2 cup honey
- 1/2 cup oil (corn, grapeseed or olive) * you can also use some applesauce to replace some of the oil if you wish*
- 1 Tablespoon Molasses
- 1 egg (beat with 1 Tbsp Water)
- 1 tsp Vanilla
Yummy ingredients
- 1/2 cup raisins (1 cup for my Dad's batch)
- 1/2 cup walnuts (more for my Dad's)!!
Preparation:
- In a large bowl, mix all the dry ingredients together.
- In a medium bowl, mix all the wet ingredients together. Hint: when measuring out the honey, spray the measuring cup with oil or baking spray--your honey won't stick).
- Mix the wet stuff with the dry stuff. Add the raisins and walnuts and mix. If the mixture seems too wet, add a bit of flour. If it isn't binding together very well, you may wish to add an egg white.
- COOL the mix for 20 minutes in the fridge.
- Preheat the oven to 335 degrees (lower temperature due to the honey in the recipe which will burn more easily).
- Drop by teaspoonfuls onto your baking sheet (I recommend lining the baking sheet with parchment paper). Press down with a fork to ensure even cooking.
- Bake for about 15 - 20 minutes or until golden on the bottom of the cookie. The cookies freeze very well and make a great snack! Enjoy.
My mom makes these wonderful cookies called "Apple cheese pleasers." They are soft oatmeal cookies with cheddar cheese and chunks of apple in them. It may sound weird but they are delicious - one of my favorites!! The oatmeal and apple combo is really nutricious, and it doesn't need much sugar or butter. I should go find that recipe...
I use 7-grain or other multigrain flour when I make oatmeal cookies. They come out much denser, but I feel that they're more flavorful as a result--and certainly better than white flour. I've been adding cranberries lately, and sometimes nuts. I also use margarine instead of butter in the recipe. Using banana instead of eggs sounds like a tasty, healthy alternative, too!
I just made Libby's "Pumpkin Perfect Oatmeal Cookies" that uses real pumpkin. I added Craisins to 1/2 the batch and chocolate chips to the other 1/2 just to try variety. They are awesome! Real pumpkin is a healthy choice. I haven't figured out the calculations yet, but adding pumpkin which is healthy (and the orange color is very festive for this time of year) sold me on these. Recipe is on Libby's website. Enjoy!
This sounds good, but about how many does it make? Did you analyze it for per cookie nutrition and calories?
ho hum... used my own recipe on this old fashioned cookie... add oats to every thing I bake,yep,pumpin pie,blackberry,blueberry,apple...substitue fruit as sugar,depends how taste BEFORE bake.
Huge disappointment calorie count! An article entitled Wholesome Oatmeal cookies with no recipe for them? What's up with that?????![]()
Gosh! I thought that including two cookies and two bars or squares would be enough. All of them are wholesome and lend themselves to substitutions as described in the article.
Use the Recipe Brower or the main CC Search to find the dozens of other oatmeal cookies submitted by CC members.
isn't this the recipe they included: Healthy Breakfast Cookie ~ http://caloriecount.about.com/healthy-breakfast-cookie-recip e-r222639
Original Post by: clairelaineGosh! I thought that including two cookies and two bars or squares would be enough. All of them are wholesome and lend themselves to substitutions as described in the article.
Use the Recipe Brower or the main CC Search to find the dozens of other oatmeal cookies submitted by CC members.
Guess some people didn't read the "fine print," i.e., the links below your text. Thanks for the article, it's very timely with the holidays coming up and all.
What can be substituted for wheat flour to make this gluten free? ...new to no wheat diet.
You can't make an oatmeal cookie gluten free...oatmeal has gluten. sorry bixlives.
Thanks for your reply, Chris. I've just read about the oat/gluten controversy and find that the gluten contained in oats is due to cross contamination from wheat and other gluten containing grains that are handled by the same mechanical processes that are used for packaging and shipping. I might try this with a brown rice flour because I really like oatmeal cookies and a little gluten isn't going to harm me.
I'm glad you posted that. My sister has celiac disease and does not eat oats at all. I read a little about the cross contaimination and studies of how those with celiac disease respond to uncontaiminated oats. I think I'd do as she is under her circumstance but if that's not why you're avoiding gluten I can see that it may not be a problem. Hope the cookies turn out well. My experiments have only had limited success but I know others who have done quite well adapting regular recipes.
Hi, I've been going through some of the oatmeal cookie recipets. Some sound great,but I found looking at the recipes they are missing ingredents in the list that are required in the instructions. I would love to make the cookies but it's missing things.
http://caloriecount.about.com/vegan-breakfast-cookies-recipe -r142330
really good, chewy oatmeal cookie
Actually you can make cookies gluten free, you just have to find gluten free oats. i can find them at places like whole foods etc... they are in the bins that you pour for yourself. Just call to ask if they have it! watch out , they are pricey! :)
Yum! That's great! Low fat, healthy and I can eat three of them for a pretty low cal count. I am SO MAKING these. Thanks heaps!
Original Post by: clairelaineGosh! I thought that including two cookies and two bars or squares would be enough. All of them are wholesome and lend themselves to substitutions as described in the article.
Use the Recipe Brower or the main CC Search to find the dozens of other oatmeal cookies submitted by CC members.
Some people are just nit-picky. I have a little cookie addiction, and this was great advice for me -- I have never thought about substituting ingredients or freezing the leftovers. Looks like I have my Saturday planned.
COOKIE TIME. ![]()
my nieces and nephew do not like the taste of oatmeal cookies. how would i make it delicious?
Original Post by: landdesignguymy nieces and nephew do not like the taste of oatmeal cookies. how would i make it delicious?
Make a different kind of cookie. They are already delicious but if somebody doesn't like oats then there's nothing that can be done. Try these
How is it that a cookie receipe with a cup of butter is only 91 calories a cookie? Is this possible? I hope!
Cool, thanks for the recipes! My fiance looooooves oatmeal cookies. He'll even eat them crushed up like cereal - yet strangely enough wont eat actual oatmeal cereal. [shrug]
advice
100
all-or-nothingthinking
american
asparagus
beans
breakfast
calorierequirements
calories
children
confidence
cooking
craving
crowdingout
dessert
diet
dieting
dinner
eatingout
eggs
emotionaleating
exercise
family
fastfood
fat
fda
fiber
fish
fooddiary
foodshopping
foodtest
friends
fruit
fullness
goals
healthy
hunger
inspiration
kids
lowcalorie
lunch
mediterranean
mediterraneandiet
mindset
motivation
party
peerpressure
plateau
portions
recipe
recipes
recommendations
restaurants
restrictivediets
salad
satiety
scale
self-esteem
sensa
shrimp
sleep
snack
snacks
soup
spring
success
successstory
sugar
support
thanksgiving
tips
tv
unsupportive
vegetables
weightloss


Related topics from the newsletter
Forums: Cookies for a bakesale Silicone bakeware Are low-calorie cookies possible?